How to replace damaged shingles: what the job involves and why it is not a DIY step
You can find damaged shingles and judge the job from the yard. The swap itself happens on the roof, and this page will not walk you through it.
To replace damaged shingles, a roofer lifts the shingles around the bad one, removes the nails, slides in a new shingle and nails it down under the course above. Every one of those moves happens on the slope. This blog leaves that part to a crew with fall protection. What you can do is find the damage, judge how big the job is and brief the roofer well.
Why this page stops before the roof
Most guides give you six steps and a pry bar. We will not write the seventh. Lifting tabs means standing on a pitched, often dusty surface, and breaking the seal on shingles that were not meant to be disturbed. Old asphalt cracks when it is bent, so a simple swap can turn into a bigger one. Our page on working at height safely explains the risk.
Spot the damage from the yard
Use binoculars in low, side light. Walk the whole house.
- Missing shingles, shown by a dark patch of underlayment or a gap in the pattern.
- Tabs that are curled, cupped or cracked across.
- Bare spots where the granules have worn off.
- Granules piled at the base of a downspout.
Photograph each spot with a date. A note like “near the chimney, left side” is not enough for a roofer. A marked photo is.
Check for water from the attic
On a dry day, take a flashlight up and look at the underside of the deck below each damaged area. Dark streaks, damp insulation or daylight tell you the water has already gotten in. Treat any growth as a sign of lasting moisture and do not try to name it. If the deck looks soft or flaky, read soft spots on a roof before anyone plans a simple swap.
What a roofer actually does
A careful roofer checks why the shingle failed before fitting a new one. A single shingle torn off by wind is a small job. A shingle that failed because of a bad nail line, a leaking flashing or a worn-out roof is a symptom. And replacing it only treats the visible part.
The new shingle also has to match the old in size and style, and the seal strip on a cold or dusty roof may need help to bond. Those are judgment calls that come from doing the work every day.
When replacing shingles stops making sense
Spot repairs suit a roof that is otherwise sound. If damage is spread across several slopes, if shingles crack as soon as they are touched. Or if the roof is near the end of its life, repeated swaps buy little. How long shingles last helps you judge where your roof stands, and repair or replace your roof walks through the decision.
Questions to ask the roofer
- Why did these shingles fail, and is the cause being fixed?
- Will the new shingles match the old ones?
- Will you check the decking under the damaged area?
- Is the flashing near the area sound?
Ask for photos of the work before and after. Our guide to hiring a roofer covers the rest.
Frequently asked questions
Can I replace damaged shingles myself?
This blog does not give DIY steps for it. The work happens on the slope, which is where falls happen, and lifting old shingles can crack the ones around them.
How do I tell which shingles are damaged?
Scan the roof from the yard with binoculars in low light. Look for missing, curled or cracked tabs and bare spots, and note any granules in the gutters.
How many damaged shingles are too many to repair?
If damage covers several slopes or the roof is near the end of its life, a full replacement often makes more sense than repeated spot repairs.
Do damaged shingles mean the roof is leaking?
Not always. Check the underside of the deck from the attic for dark streaks, damp insulation or daylight. Those show the water has gotten in.
What should I ask a roofer before a shingle repair?
Ask why the shingles failed, whether the cause will be fixed, whether the decking will be checked and whether the new shingles will match.
Sources
What this page explains is based on these official sources. If you check one and it does not match what you read here, send it to us and the article gets corrected.
- NRCA. National Roofing Contractors Association
- US OSHA. 1926.501, Duty to have fall protection (OSHA)